Capital Stock vs. Treasury Stock: Which Should You Buy?

Capital stock represents shares that a company has issued to raise funds, including both common and preferred stock available to the public. These shares give investors ownership rights and potential voting power in company decisions. Treasury stock, on the other hand, consists of shares that were previously issued but have been repurchased by the company itself. These shares don’t have voting rights or receive dividends while held by the company. It’s important to understand each option before agreeing to take ownership of either.

A financial advisor can help you with all of your financial planning needs, making it easier to decide which options are right for you.

What Is Capital Stock?

Capital stock represents the total shares a company is authorized to issue to shareholders, serving as a fundamental component of a corporation’s equity structure. When you invest in a company by purchasing shares, you’re buying a portion of its capital stock. This ownership stake gives investors certain rights, including voting privileges and potential dividend payments, depending on the specific class of shares acquired.

Capital stock generally comes in two primary varieties: common and preferred. Common stock represents basic ownership in a company. This type of stock carries voting rights but stands last in line for asset claims if the company dissolves. Preferred stock, while usually lacking voting rights, offers priority for dividend payments and asset claims. These differences make each type of capital stock suitable for different investment strategies and risk tolerances.

What Is Treasury Stock?

Treasury stock represents shares that a company has previously issued and subsequently repurchased from shareholders. When a corporation buys back its shares from the open market, these repurchased shares become treasury stock. Unlike outstanding shares, treasury stock doesn’t involve voting rights, receive dividends or have a claim on assets if the company liquidates.

Companies typically acquire treasury stock through share repurchase programs, often announced publicly to shareholders. They can execute these buybacks through open market purchases, tender offers where the company offers to buy shares at a specific price, or through private negotiations with large shareholders. The board of directors must authorize these repurchases before they can occur.

Companies repurchase their shares for several strategic reasons. For one, management can leverage treasury stock to help signal that they believe shares are undervalued, potentially boosting investor confidence. Buybacks also provide a tax-efficient alternative to dividends for returning capital to shareholders, as investors don’t pay immediate taxes on the value increase that often follows repurchase announcements.

Differences Between Capital and Treasury Stocks

Understanding the differences between capital and treasury stocks is essential for investors navigating the stock market. These two types of stock represent different aspects of a company’s financial structure and serve distinct purposes in corporate finance. Here are some distinctions of note between capital stock and treasury stock:

Ownership and issuance: Capital stock represents shares that a company has issued to investors, giving them ownership rights in the corporation. These shares are part of the company’s authorized stock. Once purchased by investors, they provide voting rights and potential dividend payments. Treasury stock, by contrast, consists of shares that were once issued but that the company itself has since repurchased.

Balance sheet treatment: Capital stock appears as equity on a company’s balance sheet, representing shareholder investment in the business. When investors purchase capital stock, they inject money into the company, increasing its assets. Treasury stock, however, is listed as a contra-equity account. It effectively reduces shareholders’ equity since the repurchased shares no longer represent outstanding ownership claims.

Dividend rights: Shareholders who own capital stock typically have the right to receive dividends when declared by the company’s board of directors. These dividend payments represent a distribution of profits to those who have invested in the company. Treasury stock, however, receives no dividends, as a company cannot pay itself dividends on shares it holds.

Voting power: Capital stock usually comes with voting rights, allowing shareholders to participate in corporate governance decisions. Treasury stock carries no voting rights while held by the company. This, in turn, reduces the number of votes that can be cast at shareholder meetings and potentially increases the voting power of remaining shareholders.

How to Decide Which Type of Stock to Invest in

Between capital stock vs. treasury stock, only the former is available to individual investors. That said, there are still several decisions an investor needs to make before investing.

First, it is important to clarify what you’re trying to achieve. Are you seeking growth, income through dividends or perhaps voting rights in a company? Your financial objectives will significantly influence which type of stock makes the most sense for your portfolio. Consider your time horizon and risk tolerance as well when evaluating which stock to invest in.

Before deciding which type of stock to invest in, thoroughly review the company’s balance sheet, cash flow and debt levels. Companies with strong fundamentals are better positioned to maintain dividend payments and potentially increase share value over time. Financial stability becomes particularly important during economic downturns.

If income is important to you, examine the company’s dividend payment history. Look for companies with consistent dividend growth over time rather than just high current yields, as this suggests sustainable financial strength.

Bottom Line

As an individual investor, you’ll typically purchase capital stock on the open market. These shares offer voting rights and the possibility of dividend income. Treasury stock isn’t directly available for purchase by individual investors, as these shares are held by the company itself and don’t confer ownership rights. When building your investment portfolio, focus on evaluating a company’s fundamentals, growth potential and dividend history. What matters most is selecting quality companies with strong performance indicators and management teams that align with your investment goals and risk tolerance.

Tips for Portfolio Management

A financial advisor can help you with portfolio management, including making sure your portfolio matches your long-term financial goals. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
An asset allocation calculator can help you understand your risk profile and what types of investments might be right for you.