What Is a Protective Tariff and How Does It Work?

A protective tariff is a type of tax imposed on imported goods to make them more expensive compared to domestic products. Governments use protective tariffs to shield local industries from foreign competition, often with the aim of encouraging the growth of domestic businesses. By increasing the price of imports, protective tariffs make locally produced goods more attractive to consumers, promoting local economic activity. However, they can also lead to higher prices for consumers and potential trade tensions.

A financial advisor can help you prepare your portfolio for economic policy changes, like new tariffs. Connect with a fiduciary advisor today.

How Protective Tariffs Work

Protective tariffs operate by raising the cost of imported goods through an additional tax, making those goods less competitive against domestically produced items. When a tariff is imposed, the importing company must pay an extra fee to bring foreign products into the country. This cost is often passed on to consumers, leading to higher retail prices for imported items compared to domestic alternatives. As a result, protective tariffs reduce the competitiveness of imports, which can benefit local manufacturers.

The mechanics of protective tariffs involve government regulations and international trade agreements. Governments may set tariff rates selectively, targeting specific industries that are deemed vulnerable or important for national economic stability. For example, sectors like steel, agriculture or textiles are often protected to maintain domestic production capacity. Protective tariffs can be part of broader economic strategies, including efforts to promote employment, foster local innovation or achieve self-sufficiency in certain industries.

While these tariffs can boost domestic production, they may also lead to retaliatory measures from other countries, affecting international trade relationships. Even though the intended effect is a more favorable market environment for local producers, allowing them to compete without being undercut by cheaper imports, the overall impact of protective tariffs can vary based on global economic dynamics.

How Protective Tariffs Impact Financial Markets

Protective tariffs can create ripple effects throughout financial markets, affecting both investors and their portfolios.

When tariffs are instituted, they can lead to increased costs for companies reliant on imported materials, which in turn can reduce profit margins. Investors might see a drop in stock prices for these companies, particularly in sectors like manufacturing, technology and consumer goods. On the other hand, companies that produce domestically and face less competition from imports may experience stock price gains, as their market position strengthens.

For average investors, tariffs can introduce volatility into the markets, leading to uncertainty in portfolio performance. In response, investors may consider diversifying their holdings to include industries that benefit from tariffs, such as domestic producers or sectors less impacted by international trade tensions. Additionally, focusing on companies with strong supply chain adaptability can help mitigate risks.

Industries That Benefit from Protective Tariffs

Protective tariffs are often designed to bolster specific domestic industries by shielding them from foreign competition. The sectors that typically benefit from these measures are those considered vital for national economic stability or growth.

Here are some of the key industries that tend to benefit from protective tariffs:

Steel and aluminum: These industries are often targeted for protection due to their importance in infrastructure and defense.
Agriculture: Farmers benefit from tariffs that limit cheaper agricultural imports, helping to maintain competitive pricing for domestic produce.
Textiles and apparel: Protective tariffs can help domestic textile manufacturers compete against low-cost foreign imports, supporting local jobs and production.
Automotive: The automotive sector can benefit from tariffs that make foreign vehicles more expensive, thereby encouraging consumers to buy domestically produced cars.
Technology and electronics: Certain high-tech sectors may benefit from tariffs that limit foreign competition, particularly when governments aim to foster innovation and local production capacity.

Industries That Suffer from Protective Tariffs

A close-up of a rubber stamp of the word tariff.

While some industries benefit from protective tariffs, others experience negative consequences. These sectors often rely on imported goods or materials and are adversely impacted by the increased costs.

Here are some of the key industries that tend to suffer from protective tariffs:

Manufacturing: Manufacturers that depend on imported raw materials may face increased production costs, which can reduce profit margins and make their products less competitive.
Retail: Retailers that import a wide range of consumer goods may experience higher costs, leading to increased prices for consumers and reduced demand.
Technology: Tech companies that rely on global supply chains for components can face significant disruptions and increased costs, affecting profitability and innovation.
Automotive: Although some domestic automakers benefit, those that rely on imported parts can face increased production costs, making their vehicles more expensive.
Consumer goods: Industries that produce consumer products using imported materials may suffer from higher input costs, leading to increased prices and potentially reduced consumer spending.

Do Tariffs Actually Work?

The effectiveness of tariffs varies based on the context and economic environment.

In some cases, protective tariffs have successfully nurtured fledgling industries by shielding them from intense foreign competition. For instance, tariffs helped the U.S. steel industry regain stability and preserve jobs during periods of economic distress. By reducing competition, tariffs allowed local producers to maintain operations and invest in growth.

However, there are also instances where tariffs have done more harm than good. They can lead to increased consumer prices, supply chain disruptions and retaliatory tariffs from trade partners. For example, the U.S.-China trade war saw both nations impose tariffs during the first Trump administration, leading to higher costs for businesses and consumers on both sides. In such scenarios, tariffs can escalate tensions and reduce overall economic efficiency, hurting both industries and consumers.

The tariffs that were instituted during Donald Trump’s first term in office (which were largely maintained by President Joe Biden) amounted to nearly $80 billion in new taxes on American consumers – “one of the largest tax increases in decades,” according to the Tax Foundation. Those tariffs, which were placed on approximately $380 billion in goods, are expected to reduce the long-term gross domestic product of the U.S. by 0.2% and result in a net loss of 142,000 jobs, the Tax Foundation estimates.

Ultimately, the success of tariffs depends on their implementation, the specific economic landscape and the reactions of trade partners.

Bottom Line

Protective tariffs are complex tools used to support domestic industries by making imports less competitive. While they can benefit certain sectors and boost local production, they also risk increasing consumer prices and sparking trade disputes. The effectiveness of tariffs ultimately depends on their implementation and the broader economic environment.

Tips for Navigating Big Policy Changes

Policy changes like new tariffs often impact specific industries or countries disproportionately. Diversification can reduce the risk of overexposure to affected areas. Avoid concentrating investments in sectors directly impacted by tariffs, such as manufacturing or agriculture. Balance your portfolio with sectors that are less likely to be affected. Also, consider non-correlated assets, like commodities or real estate, which may perform differently under changing trade conditions.
A financial advisor can help you navigate significant policy changes like new tariffs. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with up to three vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.