The Pros and Cons of Bond Index Funds

Savvy investors know diversification is one of the keys to success. That’s why bond index funds appeal to investors seeking broad market exposure. They offer a way to invest in a diversified portfolio of bonds that closely tracks a specific bond market index, often with lower costs compared to actively managed bond funds.

A financial advisor can also guide you through the process of selecting the bond index funds and other investments. Match with an advisor today.

What Is a Bond Index Fund?

A bond index fund is a diversified portfolio of bonds that are chosen to align with the performance of a specific bond index. The Barclays Aggregate U.S. Bond Index is commonly used, as it covers most U.S.-traded bonds and some foreign bonds. In a nutshell, an index seeks to track, e.g. closely match, the value or performance of the securities in that index.

Bond index funds come in many forms, including bond mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that invest in bonds.

Pros of Investing in Bond Index Funds

You can easily invest in bond index funds through an investment firm. Or, you can buy shares of a bond ETF through an online brokerage. Below, we’ll explore some of the potential advantages of investing in bond index funds.

Diversification

Some bond index funds aim to match the performance of broader indices, like those investing in the broader bond market. By mirroring an index, they provide consistent performance aligned with the overall market. These bond index funds reflect the value of the entire bond market, rather than a particular sector. This is good, because the indices that only track one market sector will underperform if that sector undergoes any kind of downturn. Bond index funds are more resilient.

Low Fees

Bond index investing is a form of passive investing. Rather than seeking to outperform the bond market, bond index funds aim to mimic it. Hence, the term “passive.” A smaller degree of management and operating costs goes into running these funds on the side of the managers. Those savings can be passed on to investors in the form of lower fees, but their passive strategy may limit flexibility in responding to market shifts.

The opposite may be true for actively managed funds. In this case, fund managers carefully select securities with an aim to beat the index. That takes a lot of management, which could mean higher fees. These fees can take a major chunk out of your return in a low-yield interest rate environment.

Consistent Payments and Transparency

Most bond funds pay interest on a monthly basis. This is different from individual bonds, which tend to pay this on a semi-annual basis. They have more transparency too, as bond fund holdings are regularly disclosed. This makes it easy for investors to understand exactly what they own in the fund.

Reduced Decision-Making Burden

With bond index funds, investors don’t need to choose individual bonds or frequently adjust their portfolios. These funds can be purchased through major brokerages. Their passive nature minimizes the need for hands-on management, making them a convenient choice for long-term investing.

Cons of Investing in Bond Index Funds

A magnifying glass highlighting a section of a finance table.

Of course, any investment comes with uncertainty. Bond index funds are no different. Here are some risks to consider before investing..

Long-Term Volatility

Most broad-based bond index funds invest in government securities, including those from the U.S. government. This means they are highly sensitive to fluctuations in the interest rate environment. When interest rates rise, bond prices typically fall, which can negatively impact the fund’s net asset value. Long-term bond index funds are particularly vulnerable to this risk due to their longer durations.

Lack of Flexibility

Bond index funds are designed to passively track a specific index. This limits their ability to adapt to market trends. For example, if interest rates rise or credit risks increase, the fund cannot actively adjust its holdings to mitigate potential losses.

Performance

Most investors consider bonds as generally safe investments, but safer investments tend to generate smaller returns. Since bond index funds aim to replicate the composition of their underlying index, they often include a significant portion of low-yield bonds. Actively managed bond funds, which may selectively invest in higher-yielding bonds, see better returns on average.

Time Horizon

When you invest in individual bonds, your risk tends to decrease as you approach the maturity date. That’s not necessarily the case with bond funds. Because they are portfolios of different bonds, the issues constantly mature and get bought or sold.

Examples of Bond Index Funds

Bond index funds are widely available from reputable investment firms, each offering unique market coverage and strategies to suit different investor needs.

The Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund (VBTLX) is a popular option that provides broad exposure to the U.S. bond market. It tracks the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index, encompassing government, corporate, and mortgage-backed securities. This fund is known for its low expense ratio and suitability for investors seeking diversification and income stability.

The Fidelity International Bond Index Fund (FBIIX) focuses on bonds issued outside the U.S., tracking the Bloomberg Global Aggregate ex-USD Index. It offers investors access to a mix of government and corporate bonds from developed and emerging markets, providing an opportunity to diversify internationally and potentially benefit from currency fluctuations.

Another well-regarded option is the Schwab U.S. Aggregate Bond Index Fund (SWAGX), which similarly tracks the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index. It is known for its affordability and focus on high credit quality securities.

For those seeking inflation protection, the iShares TIPS Bond ETF (TIP) offers exposure to U.S. Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities, which adjust for inflation to preserve purchasing power.

Are Bond Index Funds Right for You?

If you’re interested in entering the bond market, you need to know if individual bonds or bond funds are the better fit for your investment portfolio and long-term financial goals. Individual bonds are more straightforward. They typically pay an interest rate or coupon payment twice a year. And if you sell it at maturity, you get the principal back as well.

However, bond funds are composed of a variety of individual bonds. Each may have a different point of maturity so fund managers can buy and sell these at will. Bond funds typically make monthly payments, which you can keep or reinvest. Plus, they tend to climb along with interest rates. However, you won’t know when, or if, you’ll get your principal back.

Nonetheless, some fund managers try to increase their funds’ income payments when interest rates rise by buying newer bonds with the higher coupon rates. In addition, you can reinvest your monthly income payments to buy new shares.

You may also consider investing in growth-oriented securities, like equities, rather than focusing solely on bonds or bond funds. These can include stock index funds, which historically have outperformed bond markets. So if you have a long time horizon and a high risk tolerance, equities, not bond index funds, are right for you.

How to Choose a Bond Index Fund

Start by thinking about your goals. Do you want broad exposure to the bond market? Or something more specific, like government or corporate bonds? Some funds track the entire market, while others focus on one type of bond.

Consider your investment time frame. Short-term bond funds tend to be less affected by interest rate changes and may work better if you need the money soon. Long-term bond funds can offer more income but may come with more price swings. For protection against inflation, look at funds that include Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS).

Next, think about the fund’s risk level. Funds that hold high-quality bonds, such as government-backed securities, are usually more stable. Funds with lower-quality bonds might offer higher yields but carry more risk. Check the fund’s fees, too. Bond index funds are generally low-cost, but some charge even less than others. Lower expenses can help you keep more of your return over time.

Decide whether you prefer an ETF or a mutual fund. ETFs can be bought and sold throughout the trading day and may have lower trading costs. Mutual funds only trade once per day after the market closes.

Make sure the bond index fund fits with the rest of your investment portfolio. If you’re focused on income and stability, look for funds with less risk. If you’re aiming for long-term growth, you may consider a fund with a broader mix of bonds.

Bottom Line

Arrows pointing up on an investment tracker, indicating a positive trend.

Investing in bond index funds can increase your exposure to safer, low-fee securities. You may benefit from diversifying your investments to include exposure to other types of securities, such as stock funds. Always pay attention to your risk tolerance and time horizon when building your portfolio and determining your asset allocation. But you may also encounter some hidden risks. Bond funds that invest heavily in government-backed securities, for example, may be highly volatile in a high interest rate environment.

Investing Tips

A financial advisor can help you ensure that you’re making the right decisions for your financial life. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
If you’re not sure how to divvy up your investments, use our asset allocation calculator. It can help you visualize what a diversified portfolio may look like based on varying risk tolerance levels.