tastytrade vs. thinkorswim

Today, there’s a vast array of online financial services designed to help every type of investor. Some businesses find niches in the market and develop newer platforms to address those needs. That’s where tastytrade and thinkorswim come in. These two investing services have made a name for themselves by balancing low costs with complex trading tools. However, small differences can make or break each platform, depending on the investor. When comparing tastytrade vs. thinkorswim, this is what to consider to determine which one is right for you.

Investing on your own can be challenging, but professional help is available. Consider speaking with a financial advisor about your investing and retirement questions.

Overview of tastytrade vs. thinkorswim

There are certainly similarities when comparing tastytrade vs. thinkorswim, a Charles Schwab trading platform. For example, the two platforms share comparable pricing when trading stocks and exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

However, the platforms differ in their emphasis and available tools. tastytrade is geared toward active traders, particularly those trading options and other derivatives. thinkorswim, meanwhile, offers extensive customization, advanced charting, market data and research tools through Charles Schwab.

Despite their features, both tastytrade and thinkorswim come with a steep learning curve so they may not be the best choice for beginners to investing.

tastytrade vs. thinkorswim: Fees

If you are using a trading platform like Zacks Trade or Fidelity, be sure to research the types of fees you will encounter. Common fees include:

Trading Fees. Trading fees are any fixed charge attached to each trade that you make. This is often a flat fee that is known as the spread. It applies when your broker charges you based on the difference between the buying and selling prices of an asset, if any exists.
Trading Commissions. Trading commissions are typically charged by your broker and represent a percentage based on the volume or value of each trade.
Inactivity Fees. Inactivity fees are charges your broker imposes for not trading regularly, such as when you keep money in a brokerage account.
Non-Trading/Other Fees. There may also be additional fees that apply to a specific platform. For example, a brokerage may charge you for making deposits or withdrawals into your brokerage account or for signing up for additional services.

Neither tastytrade nor thinkorswim charges you anything to trade stocks and ETFs. Additionally, there are no maintenance or inactivity fees when using either platform.

The two brokers are similar in their charges, although the exact costs differ a bit.

For example, both services charge for options and futures contracts. In particular, tastytrade was built with options traders in mind. tastytrade charges $1 per contract to open stock and ETF options positions and $0 to close them, with commissions capped at $10 per leg. In contrast, thinkorswim charges $0.65 for options per contract.

Schwab may also charge up to $74.95 to purchase certain mutual funds that aren’t available through its Mutual Fund OneSource service. A broker-assisted trading service is also available for $25. Both brokers charge interest on margin borrowing, with rates generally varying based on the size of the debit balance. Investors should check each brokerage’s current margin rates before borrowing.

tastytrade vs. thinkorswim: Services & Features

tastytrade is primarily geared toward active and derivatives traders, with access to stocks, ETFs, options, futures, options on futures, cryptocurrency and forex. The platform has also expanded its fixed-income offerings to include investments such as Treasury bills. Investors looking for mutual funds or a broader selection of traditional investments may still find Schwab’s overall brokerage offering more comprehensive.

Still, there are certain notable features that tastytrade offers. First, the interface allows multiple order types. You can easily enter multi-leg trades and either replace or cancel them. tastytrade has a Follow Feed, similar to social media platforms like Twitter, so you can view what your favorite traders are doing with their portfolios. You can also enjoy access to videos, articles and daily content on investment-related topics to grow their knowledge.

For its part, thinkorswim supplies in-depth details about its stocks, including the price and options chain. However, its analysis feature and investing resources are really what makes it shine. There may be a lot to work through, but investors can access advanced charting, company and market data, news and Level II quotes, which tastytrade does not currently offer.

thinkorswim also parallels tastytrade in its complex list of order types. The platform encourages customization throughout trading. If it feels overwhelming, you can test the program using its paper trading mode. With thinkorswim paperMoney, you can set up a simulated account and trade with fake money until you are comfortable with the system.

tastytrade’s The Works account provides its highest level of trading permissions, including access to advanced options and futures strategies. Eligible investors can also apply separately for portfolio margin, which has additional balance and approval requirements.

tastytrade vs. thinkorswim: Online & Mobile Experience

thinkorswim is available through desktop, web and mobile platforms and is primarily designed for active, hands-on investors. Its platforms emphasize customization, advanced trading tools and investor research rather than prebuilt portfolios.

The exact features vary by platform, but mobile and web users can access many of the same charting, market data and trading tools available through the desktop software.

If you hit a snag, thinkorswim customers have the option to contact them through chat services or over the phone if needed. Schwab is one of the largest investment organizations in the U.S. and has the resources for a strong customer service network.

tastytrade is available through desktop, web and mobile platforms. Its mobile app includes trading, position-management and market-monitoring tools for investors who want to manage their accounts on the go.

The service is dense like thinkorswim’s, though, and comes with little guidance, making it more challenging for those new to investing.

tastytrade vs. thinkorswim: Education and Research Resources

Both tastytrade and thinkorswim aim to equip investors with robust educational tools and research resources, although they approach this in slightly different ways. For investors who value education while they trade, these differences can help determine which platform better suits their needs.

tastytrade places a strong emphasis on investor education, particularly for active traders and those interested in options. The platform offers daily live shows, tutorials and market commentary produced by its own media team. These shows often feature professional traders walking through real trades, market analysis and risk management strategies.

tastytrade also hosts an extensive library of on-demand videos, blog articles and strategy guides that cater to both intermediate and advanced traders. Its Follow Feed even lets users watch what experienced traders are doing in real time, blending education with actionable insight.

thinkorswim, meanwhile, is backed by Schwab’s extensive educational resources and caters to a broader audience, covering the basics of investing while also appealing to seasoned traders.

One of its standout features is its paper trading simulator, which allows you to practice trading with virtual funds in a risk-free environment. thinkorswim offers market screeners, Level II quotes, live news, customizable charts and advanced analytical tools. Users also have access to Schwab’s broader educational resources, including demos, webinars and online learning materials covering topics ranging from investing basics to technical analysis.

Overall, tastytrade focuses on actionable, trader-specific education, backed by a strong media presence. However, thinkorswim provides a wider range of research tools and hands-on learning opportunities for traders at all skill levels.

If you prefer daily insights and a community-driven approach, tastytrade may be a better fit. If you want a more traditional education suite with simulation tools and professional-grade analytics, thinkorswim stands out.

Who Should Use tastytrade?

Overall, tastytrade is suited to highly active investors engaged in derivatives trading with a basic framework for high-volume and high-speed options trading. The lower costs compared to other services may be enticing to newer investors, but the service’s complicated layout may take awhile to learn. However, there are resources to help you learn how to use it effectively.

If you want to focus on IRA accounts, mutual funds or long-term assets in general, you may be better off looking elsewhere.

Who Should Use thinkorswim?

thinkorswim is a semi-professional system that even advanced traders may struggle to navigate. That means hobbyists and novices might find this platform more trouble than its worth. Overall, this is a trading platform best suited to active, hands-on investors with experience.

If you like thinkorswim but do not need all its features, Schwab’s standard web platform may be a suitable alternative.

Bottom Line

When comparing tastytrade vs. thinkorswim, both platforms cater largely to active investors and offer sophisticated tools for options trading. tastytrade places a heavier emphasis on derivatives trading and trader-focused education, while thinkorswim offers particularly extensive charting, market data and analytical tools. Schwab’s broader brokerage platform also provides access to investment products that aren’t available directly through thinkorswim or tastytrade, giving investors another factor to consider when choosing between the two.

Consider finding a financial advisor who can help you make the decisions based on your long-term goals and risk tolerance.

Investing Tips

Consider working with a financial advisor who can help you create and manage your investment portfolio. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with up to three vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
Make sure your investment assets fit your risk profile. SmartAsset’s free, easy-to-use asset allocation calculator will help align your assets with your risk tolerance.