Defined Benefit Plans for the Self-Employed

Unlike other retirement plans, a defined benefit plan for the self-employed promises a specific payout upon retirement. This calculation uses factors such as salary history and duration of employment. This plan allows for significant tax-deferred contributions, often exceeding those permitted in standard retirement accounts. However, establishing a defined benefit plan requires meticulous calculations and annual contributions to build a plan for a steady retirement income. For self-employed professionals seeking substantial retirement savings, a defined benefit plan can be a strategic choice.

A financial advisor can help you create the right plan to suit your retirement needs.

Understanding Defined Benefit Plans

Defined benefit plans are a powerful retirement savings tool, particularly for self-employed individuals looking to maximize their retirement contributions.

These plans promise a specific retirement benefit amount. The formula considers factors such as salary history, life expectancy and length of employment. Unlike defined contribution plans, where the end benefit depends on investment returns, defined benefit plans offer a predictable retirement income.

For self-employed individuals, defined benefit plans can be particularly advantageous.

• Generous contribution limits. These plans allow high contribution limits. This can be beneficial for those who start saving later in life or who have fluctuating incomes.
• Tax deductions. Contributions are tax-deductible, up to IRS limits, and the benefits grow tax-deferred until retirement.
• Greater contributions than other plans. How you calculate contributions depends on the desired retirement benefit and the number of years until retirement. This enables substantial contributions, often exceeding those allowed in other retirement plans.

The contribution limits for defined benefit plans are not set as in defined contribution plans. Instead, they are actuarially determined using factors such as age, income and retirement goals.

For self-employed individuals, this means the ability to make significantly higher contributions, especially as they approach retirement. These contributions can range from hundreds of thousands of dollars annually to zero, depending on individual circumstances.

There are three types of plans for the self-employed.

Traditional Defined Benefit Plans

Traditional defined benefit plans calculate retirement benefits using a specific formula. This is based on earnings and years of service.

For self-employed individuals, this means establishing a plan that considers their earnings history and future earnings projections.

Cash Balance Defined Benefit Plans

Cash balance defined benefit plans combine features of both defined benefit and defined contribution plans. Each participant has an individual account that grows annually both from employer contributions and an interest credit.

For self-employed individuals, cash balance plans offer flexibility and the potential for higher contributions than traditional defined benefit plans. However, if you have employees, you will likely have to fund their pensions too.

Fully Insured Defined Benefit Plans

A fully insured defined benefit plan is a type of plan backed by insurance contracts. These plans guarantee a certain retirement benefit, regardless of the performance of underlying investments.

For self-employed individuals, this option can offer a high degree of security and predictability. The contributions can buy insurance products that can promise benefits.

Benefits of Defined Benefit Plans

One of the primary benefits of a defined benefit plan for the self-employed is the guarantee of a specific retirement income.

Unlike other retirement plans that depend on market performance, a defined benefit plan provides a predictable, steady income stream. This can be particularly reassuring for self-employed individuals who might not have the luxury of employer-sponsored retirement benefits.

Defined benefit plans also offer substantial tax advantages. Contributions to the plan are typically tax-deductible, allowing self-employed individuals to significantly reduce their taxable income.

Additionally, the funds within the plan grow tax-deferred, which can lead to considerable savings over time. For those in higher tax brackets, this can be an effective strategy to manage tax liabilities while building a robust retirement fund. However, note that withdrawals are fully taxable.

Another compelling feature is the high contribution limits. Unlike defined contribution plans, which cap annual contributions, defined benefit plans allow much larger contributions.

This can be particularly advantageous for self-employed individuals with high incomes or those looking to catch up on retirement savings later in their careers. The ability to make substantial contributions can accelerate the retirement fund’s growth.

Drawbacks of Defined Benefit Plans

Setting up and maintaining defined benefit plans requires a significant administrative effort.

This often involves hiring actuaries and other professionals to calculate contributions and comply with regulatory requirements. These services can be expensive, increasing the plan’s overall cost.

Another major drawback is the mandatory funding requirements. The IRS charges an excise tax on any unfunded amount based on the minimum required contribution. This can be challenging for self-employed individuals with fluctuating incomes, as they must meet the funding obligations even during leaner financial periods.

Defined benefit plans also lack the flexibility found in other retirement savings options. Once you establish the plan, altering the terms can be complex and costly. This rigidity can be a disadvantage for self-employed individuals whose financial situations may change over time.

Furthermore, accessing funds early before age 59 ½ or termination of service can result in significant penalties, making it less adaptable to changing financial needs.

Setting Up a Defined Benefit Plan as a Self-Employed Individual

Typically, a defined benefit plan is suitable for those with stable, high-income levels who can consistently contribute significant amounts. To set up these plans, self-employed individuals must meet specific eligibility criteria.

The first step in setting up a defined benefit plan for self-employed individuals involves consulting with a financial advisor or retirement plan specialist. This professional can help design a plan that aligns with your retirement goals and complies with IRS regulations. They will formailly write your plan and detail the benefits formula. This usually considers factors such as age, salary and years of service.

Once you establish the plan, consistent funding is important. You generally calculate contributions using actuarial assumptions, ensuring you receive the promised benefits upon retirement.

Regular reviews and adjustments by an actuary are necessary to maintain the plan’s funding status and compliance.

Defined Benefit Plans vs. Other Self-Employed Retirement Options

A defined benefit plan isn’t right for everyone, but it is not the only option available to self-employed individuals. Understanding how it stacks up against other common plans can help you decide whether the added cost and complexity are worth it.

SEP IRA

A SEP IRA is one of the simplest options.

It allows contributions of up to 25% of net self-employment income, with a maximum of $72,000 for 2026. ¹ There’s minimal paperwork and no annual filing requirement below certain thresholds.

The downside is that the percentage-based cap means you need a fairly high income to reach the maximum contribution. There’s no Roth option or catch-up provision for older savers.

For self-employed individuals who want solid contribution limits without administrative burden, a SEP IRA is often the starting point.

Solo 401(k)

A Solo 401(k) offers more flexibility.

It allows both employee and employer contributions, with a combined limit of $72,000 for 2026. There is an additional $8,000 catch-up contribution for those 50 and older, or $11,250 for those ages 60 to 63. ²

It also offers a Roth option, which a SEP IRA does not. The paperwork is more involved than a SEP IRA, and an annual Form 5500-EZ filing is required once assets exceed $250,000 ³ , but it’s still relatively manageable.

For self-employed individuals with no employees who want higher contribution potential at moderate income levels, a Solo 401(k) is a strong middle ground.

SIMPLE IRA

A SIMPLE IRA has lower contribution limits. These are capped at $17,000 in employee deferrals for 2026 with a $4,000 catch-up for those 50 and older, or $5,250 for ages 60 to 63. ⁴

It’s designed for small businesses with employees and is easier to administer than a 401(k). However, the savings capacity is limited for high earners. It’s generally a better fit for small business owners who want to offer a retirement benefit to their team rather than maximize their own contributions.

How Defined Benefit Plans Compare

A defined benefit plan sits at the other end of the spectrum.

Because contributions are actuarially determined, they can reach well over $200,000 annually, depending on age, income and years to retirement. That makes it the highest-capacity savings vehicle available to self-employed individuals.

However, it’s also the most expensive to set up and maintain. Annual actuarial calculations and contributions are mandatory, and professional administration is ongoing each year, regardless of how the business performs. The cost of running the plan typically runs several thousand dollars per year.

For many self-employed individuals, a SEP IRA or Solo 401(k) provides enough savings capacity at a fraction of the cost. A defined benefit plan tends to make the most sense for high earners, particularly those in their 40s or 50s, who want to put away significantly more than other plans allow and can commit to consistent annual funding over a period of years.

Some self-employed individuals also layer a defined benefit plan on top of a Solo 401(k) to maximize total tax-deferred contributions in a given year.

Bottom Line

Choosing a defined benefit plan for self-employed individuals can significantly enhance retirement security. These plans offer the advantage of predictable, guaranteed income post-retirement, which is particularly appealing for stability over market fluctuations. Unlike other retirement savings options, defined benefit plans allow for higher contribution limits, making them an attractive choice for self-employed professionals with the means to maximize their retirement savings.

Retirement Planning Tips

• Building a nest egg can be complicated. A financial advisor can help you analyse investments and create a plan for your retirement. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.     
• If you want to figure out how much you should save for retirement, SmartAsset’s calculator can help you get an estimate.

Photo credit: ©iStock.com/FreshSplash, ©iStock.com/damircudic, ©iStock.com/mdphoto16