Executive Deferred Compensation Plans

Are you maxing out the 401(k) plan you have at work every year? Do you still have money left after contributing the maximum to your 401(k) and maybe an IRA or two? If so, then you may want to consider contributing to an executive deferred compensation plan. These plans can provide another way for some highly compensated employees to save for retirement. However, they carry different risks and withdrawal rules than a standard 401(k).

A financial advisor can help you build a retirement strategy based on your long-term needs and goals.

Executive Deferred Compensation Plans Defined

An executive deferred compensation plan allows eligible employees to postpone receiving part of their compensation. The plan defers any income taxes owed until you actually receive the money. Unlike a 401(k), a nonqualified deferred compensation plan does not provide participants with a separate, protected retirement account. Instead, the deferred amount generally remains an obligation of the employer.

This arrangement can be particularly useful for employees who have already reached the contribution limits on tax-advantaged retirement accounts. In 2026, employees can defer up to $24,500 into a 401(k), with an additional $8,000 catch-up contribution for participants age 50 and older. The higher catch-up limit for participants ages 60 through 63 is $11,250. ¹

Participants in an executive deferred compensation plan generally make elections about when and how they will receive their money. Those choices matter because federal tax rules place restrictions on when distributions can occur. They also restrict when you can change elections. The timing decision is made well before the money is paid, which can make long-range planning difficult. An employee’s eventual retirement year, earnings, and other sources of income may look very different by the time payments begin.

It is also necessary to specify how you want to take your distribution. Your plan may include receiving the balance at once or dividing payments among multiple tax years. Changes to an existing election are subject to strict rules, so participants generally have much less flexibility than they would with withdrawals from an IRA or 401(k). Section 409A sets requirements for deferral elections and distributions from NQDC plans.

Offering employees access to an executive deferred compensation plan can help employers recruit and retain highly compensated employees. Companies do not necessarily make these plans available throughout their workforce. Eligibility depends on the employer’s program and the employees it covers.

Types and Categories of Deferred Compensation Plans

There are two broad categories of retirement and deferred compensation arrangements: qualified and nonqualified plans. Qualified retirement plans are subject to federal requirements that do not apply in the same way to NQDC plans. A 401(k), for example, has annual contribution limits and participant protections that an executive NQDC plan does not.

Executive deferred compensation plans act as generally nonqualified plans, or NQDCs. Because they do not receive the same treatment as qualified retirement plans, employers can restrict eligibility to selected employees and allow deferrals above the limits that apply to a 401(k).

Executive deferred compensation can take several forms. Salary and bonus deferral arrangements allow an employee to postpone receiving compensation they otherwise would have received currently. Supplemental executive retirement plans (SERPs) and excess benefit plans can instead provide employer-funded benefits that supplement qualified retirement benefits. The specific funding, vesting, and distribution provisions depend on the employer’s plan.

Pros and Cons of Executive Deferred Compensation Plans

The main appeal of an executive deferred compensation plan is the ability to postpone income beyond the limits of a qualified retirement plan. But that additional tax deferral comes with restrictions and financial risks that are not present in the same way with a 401(k).

Pros

• NQDC plans are not subject to the same employee contribution limit as a 401(k), although an employer can set its own deferral limits.
• Deferring compensation can reduce taxable income in the year you would have received the income. Taxes become due when the deferred compensation finally enters your account.
• A participant who expects to have a lower taxable income in retirement may wish to receive deferred compensation during lower-income years. However, you don’t always know your future tax rates and income in advance.
• Employers can design plans for specific groups of highly compensated employees rather than offering them to the entire workforce.

Cons

• Deferred compensation generally remains subject to the employer’s creditors. If the company becomes insolvent, participants can lose some or all of the amount they expected to receive.
• The plan terms and federal tax rules limit access to the money. A participant generally cannot withdraw NQDC money whenever needed in the same way that certain distributions may be available from a 401(k).
• NQDC balances generally cannot be rolled into an IRA or a new employer’s 401(k) when you leave your job.
• NQDC plans generally do not offer participant loans.
• Investment choices or the method used to credit returns may be more limited than the options available through a 401(k).

Another important distinction involves required minimum distributions (RMDs). The previous age-72 rule no longer applies. Traditional 401(k) accounts are generally subject to RMD rules beginning at age 73 under current law, although some workers can delay distributions from their current employer’s plan until retirement. The applicable RMD age rises to 75 for younger cohorts under SECURE 2.0. ² NQDC distributions instead follow the payment schedule established under the plan.

Deciding on an Executive Deferred Compensation Program

Before electing to defer part of your compensation, compare the plan with the other places you could put that money. The decision involves more than whether you can lower your current taxable income.

• Start with your 401(k). At a minimum, consider contributing enough to receive the full employer match. Higher earners may also want to compare an NQDC election with maxing out the 401(k), including any catch-up contribution for which they qualify.
• Review your expected cash needs. Money committed to an NQDC plan may be unavailable for years, so funds needed for near-term expenses, an emergency fund or other financial goals may be better kept elsewhere.
• Choose the distribution schedule carefully. A large lump sum could push more income into higher tax brackets in a single year, while installment payments can spread taxable income across several years.
• Consider the employer’s financial condition. Because NQDC benefits generally remain exposed to the employer’s creditors, deferring a large amount can increase your financial dependence on the same company that already provides your salary and possibly company stock or other benefits.
• Review how returns are credited. Some plans offer investment-based benchmarks, while others use a stated rate or another formula. The plan document should explain how your deferred balance changes over time.
• Consider when you expect other retirement income to begin. Pension payments, Social Security, IRA withdrawals, and RMDs can all affect your taxable income during the years when NQDC distributions arrive.

How Much Income Should You Defer?

The amount you can afford to defer may be very different from the amount your employer allows. Before making an election, start with the income you expect to need for the coming year. Money left after things like taxes and cost of living can then be evaluated for longer-term savings.

For example, assume you earn $300,000 and already contribute the 2026 maximum of $24,500 to your 401(k). If you are considering deferring another $50,000 through an NQDC plan, your decision should account for whether you can comfortably give up access to that $50,000 until the scheduled distribution date. The immediate tax deferral alone does not make the election appropriate if doing so leaves you short of cash.

Next, look at the years when the money will come back to you. Someone retiring at 65 might schedule installment payments from ages 65 through 69, for example, rather than taking the entire balance at retirement. Spreading distributions may help avoid concentrating a large amount of taxable income in one year. Your other expected income during that period should be part of the calculation.

Consider how much of your personal finances already depends on the company before committing more pay to the plan. Your paycheck may already represent a major connection to your employer, and other benefits could increase that exposure. Keeping part of your savings elsewhere gives you assets that do not depend on the company’s ability to meet a future payment obligation.

A practical annual review can compare your expected spending, 401(k) and IRA contributions, taxable savings, future income and planned NQDC distributions before you make a new deferral election. A financial advisor can help calculate how much income you can defer without leaving too little available for current needs or creating an unnecessarily large taxable distribution later.

Bottom Line

Executive deferred compensation plans can give highly compensated employees another tax-deferred savings option after they have made use of traditional retirement accounts. They can also expose participants to employer credit risk, restricted access to their money and an inflexible distribution schedule. Before making an election, consider how much income you can afford to defer, when the payments will arrive, your expected tax situation during those years and how much of your financial future is already tied to your employer.

Tips for Retirement

• Retirement planning is complex so it makes a lot of sense to engage a financial advisor as you work through the various aspects of it. Finding a qualified financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
• Use the SmartAsset retirement calculator to estimate how much money you will need in retirement. It will help you determine if you should invest in an executive deferred compensation program.

Photo credit: ©iStock.com/PeopleImages, ©iStock.com/EXTREME-PHOTOGRAPHER, ©iStock.com/metamorworks